hollow bastion

You have any suggestions for my set?

D/J/T

I suggest you move the BR's closer to the center by 1 space, because you won't reach the cleric with 2 moves for most grey turtles. Also I would put a chanty in. But the witches are alright. And maybe try putting the scout and mud on the same side so the scout can reach one corner, and mud can reach the other, because your scout right now most likely can only hit the left corner.
I'm not sure if I explained that very well...

__________________

hollow bastion

thx a ton

F13

As mostly a turt player i would use a turt with the Br's and witches. But that is my idea, you seem to be a rusher so.. Ya dont lisen to a turter like meself >.<

Gypsy

Hmm, I don't agree with those changes. If you swap the brs with the mud and scout you put them in lw range, which is a bad idea, you can live without the brs, esp since you can then use your witch on that side. Then if they take the witch you move with the br and keep the scout/mud for support. The scout and mud are fine where they are, they can easily get to either side from the center. Scout has about everything covered. Maybe swap it with the center knight so the scout is then centered. Keeping the scout and mud centered keeps up your versatility. Bank them on one side and you would have what I would consider and opp. side game with that form, which is not the idea.

I'd also say there isn't much of a purpose for an enchantress in the formation, especially because it unbalances the line. Also, what would you take out? You need the mud and scout, plus a br and a witch for each side.

When you get the units I recommend removing the witch and adding a frost and another br. I'm using that and it seems to be working well in most scenarios. I did lost to uall in free by 2 units though. Only loss with it so far. >_>

Another interesting form is the old witch rush, to do that sub in 2 more witches for the 2 brs. You may also want to try that when you get a 4th witch. Always good to experiment and see what works for you.

/2cents

Not to pick your suggestion apart or anything DJT. ;)

bigdaddyj1981

get a couple more witchs and another rider and this set works great for me. i use the riders and scout or muddy to get clerics then the witchs clean house

__________________


http://www.freewebs.com/bigdaddyj1981

jeanne d'arc

mmmh... i'd change witch position as they're in common LW position: You wouldn't like to start with 1 unit disadvantage :P

look at this set made by Brutalrage

1CL-1SC-1MU-3KN-2BR-2WI

BRs and scout are centered, mud is a bit luck searching: if it's same side it would be very strong there, but opposite side it can just move into enemy in 2 moves.

witches are there as threat: they can take out eventually wounded units, frontline rush, or simply have the range u would need if battling someone with frost.

knight are well positioned by helping the faster (but fragiler) units, by blocking side hits. two of them are quite centered so they have the opponent flank, the last one can eventually infiltrate in a hole when opponent has to retreat his units (especially scout in front of the witch)

I hope that can be helpful,
I apologize for my really bad English grammar

Jeannette

__________________
A warrior takes Sword in hand,
clasping a gem to his heart
Engraving vanishing memories into the sword
he places finely honed skills into the stone
Spoken from the sword,
handed down from the stone
Now the story can be told...

hollow bastion

yea i hope to take out witches, die too fast, but cant put in another br or frost

hollow bastion

thx allc

LoSt SouL

Put the witches on the wall. Can't get LW'd unless the LW is in a very strange position, and that way you can get free attacks. I dislike your br positions though. Too easy to hit. I suggest the center being Mud and scout next to each other and then beasties on the sides

__________________